Call It A Flop: Mariah Carey’s Latest LP Debuts Unimpressively

I’ve been saying it all along, and as much as I hate being wrong, I hoped I’d be wrong this time. Unfortunately (or “just like I told y’all”), I was correct about Mariah Carey’s forthcoming LP Me. I Am Mariah…The Elusive Chanteuse being a flop. The album itself is no flop, which was something of a surprise in itself. Sure it is flawed, but Me also shows some superb MC moments as well.

Mariah Carey2-20140210-2However, the numbers don’t lie, particularly first week numbers for an album with no hit single to rely upon. Me only managed to sell 58,000 copies. Not only is that below prognostications (60,000 – 65,000), but it gives Carey a reverse career milestone… her lowest, most tepid sales number.

While there are exceptions, the amount of copies that an album sells in within its first week is “kind of a big deal”. Why – because those numbers sort of establish the ceiling for the album. Typically, anything below 100,000 copies is likely not going to stay hot very long commercially.

Although August Alsina had a respectable first week with a no. 2 debut and 67,000 copies sold, the ceiling for Alsina after percentage drops in sales each week seems small. A larger first week sum usually gives the album itself a higher ceiling. Take Coldplay’s Ghost Stories; it spent its first week at no. 1 selling 383,000 copies and this week sells another 83,000 copies. If nothing more, Ghost Stories is already sitting at gold certification from the RIAA.

As for Carey, 58,000 copies doesn’t seem at all promising. With only a potential 50% drop in sales, Carey would only sell 29,000 copies. Why didn’t Me sell – Here are some reasons why Mimi might have struggled.

Album Release Delays/Hiatus 

There’s an unwritten cardinal rule somewhere: you can’t delay an album and expect it to sell. Even if you are Mariah Carey, the name along won’t sell and album that has been delayed so many times. The proof is in the pudding… or the sales numbers rather.   Another point worth noting is that a lengthy hiatus, particularly for an older artist, can definitely hurt the market for that artist, no matter their veteran status.Mariah Carey-MSA-019655

Tepid Promotion

The promotional campaign for Me leaves plenty to be desired. One gargantuan problem is the lack of a currently successful single. When “#Beautiful” was hot (or at least lukewarm), Mariah Carey should’ve jumped on that and dropped this album. That’s not to say she needed to rush and release crap, but it is to say that she should’ve been mindful of the “drop it when it’s hot”rule. Instead, more and more singles came with none latching or causing excitement.

Even Kanye West knows that the lack of a big single can hurt sales – ask him about Yeezus. With nothing to offer the listener, can you really expect the album to sell, particularly these days? (The answer is no).

Expensive Pricing

For a comeback album, Def Jam certainly wanted a pretty penny for any version of Me, which was released in standard and deluxe editions. The problem with being pricey, even given the amount of tracks on the album, is that people don’t want to make the investment. Sure $13 – $20 isn’t the end all be all, but for a CD that you know little about and without consistent airplay, paying that much is deal breaker.  More people might’ve purchased Me if it were just a bit cheaper…

Mariah Carey3-20140210-1


…And then again, maybe people wouldn’t have purchased it if it were more reasonably priced. Why? Mariah Carey is no ‘spring chicken’ – she is ‘old’ by music industry standards. Mariah can continue to parade around like she’s in her twenties or even thirties again, but she ain’t. Even the best in the business wane after a while. That doesn’t mean that their legacy or legend isn’t important, but they certainly aren’t going to compete well with more youthful artists most of the time.

Ultimately, things don’t look good for MC – perhaps that’s an understatement in itself.   Unless Carey finds a hit that’ll appeal, Me. I Am Mariah…The Elusive Chanteuse definitely has ‘flop’ written all over it. At this point, looks like Def Jam can prepare the eulogy.

3 Comments Add yours

  1. my take. she got weak to generic songs which nothing stands out 1) she ain’t really singing, she is still doing that coy act she did back in her prime and peak 2) she don’t care about making no records no more because she is paid and got taken care and ain’t hurting for loot 3)what can anybody bring her musically that she didn’t already do 10,15 or 20 years back?4) record company ain’t caring about her when they got Beyonce, RHianna,katy perry,Iggy,etc..5)

  2. Kit says:

    It may have flopped in sales but that is quite unfortunate. I only say this because as a 24 year fan of Mariah’s and one who owns all her records, I have to honestly say that this album is one of if not her very best overall albums ever. She sounds the best in years. Her voice is strong on this record. The songs are great! I hate that people aren’t hearing some of her best stuff in her whole career. I challenge anyone who’s ever liked her music to get this record. You won’t regret it!

    1. brent80 says:

      I agree it is one of her better albums in some time. I definitely think it should have sold more!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.